I think this is long enough on it’s own that I’ll have to make my comments on it elsewhere. The only thing I absolutly must say is that my life would have been so much different if my mother felt this way, or at least said she felt this way. When I feel like shit, reading this helps. That and the names have been changed to protect the blah blah blah.
Sometimes I’m better at putting my thoughts down on paper rather than saying them out loud…so I thought I’d write you this letter to tell you some things I’ve been wanting to say… but can’t seem to find the right words or exactly the right time to say them.
I’m not sure exactly where to begin—so I guess I’ll just start at the very beginning!! I remember when you were born very clearly, even though I was only about eight years old at the time. Dad took me and Sister #2 (who was only 6) to the hospital to see you when you were first born. He was absolutely tickled and beaming… He had a perpetual smile on his face. I remember standing there with him in the hospital, staring down at you laying in the little glass hospital baby bed… all wrapped up in your baby blankets, as pretty a baby that ever was. I think I even got to hold you… It was terribly exciting and we just fell in love with you the minute we saw you.
When you were first born, the three of you lived in the house in Pontiac that had belonged to Aunt and Uncle, and Sister #2 and I visited frequently for that first summer (summer of 1981, I think). It was the one time in my childhood, other than when I lived with you in Chicago, that I saw Dad semi-regularly. I turned 9 that June after you were born, and I remember that I had a little birthday party at the house with you and Dad and your Mom. It was one of the only birthdays I had with Dad in my life. Your mom made me a cake, I think it was strawberry, and it had a little white plastic dove on top of it. I still have the little plastic dove in my jewelry box, although one wing is broken (is that symbolic of something??)
)
I have really fond memories of that summer- of you as a baby and of Dad playing his 12 string guitar in the living room of that house for me and Sister #2. He’d play that guitar and sing Beatles songs and Supertramp songs for us—which we absolutely adored.
I don’t clearly remember how long you lived in that house, but at some point the three of you moved to the apartment that was near Oak Hill Cemetery in Pontiac. I remember visiting you there at least once, and I recall that you were teething, and Dad was explaining to me that you were going to be moving to Chicago. Although I didn’t have a realistic idea of how far away that was, it might as well have been half way across the world. I was really sad because I knew it meant that I wasn’t going to see him or you as much, and deep down I knew already that it meant it would be even longer than Dad said it was going to be.
I remember you and Dad and your Mom coming to visit us in Michigan after that once or twice. One time was up north in Kalkaska before Grandma and Grandpa sold the property. I can remember that it was winter… which was unusual. I think I only went up there one time in my life in the winter, and it was with you and Dad and your Mom. I remember it seemed like there was about 4 feet of snow… I’m sure it was less, and it seemed like more because I was small. I also remember the three of you coming to stay at Judy’s house when you were maybe 1 or 2 years old. I was in fourth grade. It may have been a year or so later (you were about 3, I think) that Dad drove from Chicago with you to visit us and we all went to Greenfield Village. It was just you and Dad at that point, I think your Mom had moved out. It must have been after that when Dad had to move to Florida with you to live next door to Grandma and Grandpa. Sister #2 and I got to visit you that summer when Dad lived in the trailer… Were you 4? Or still 3? I can’t remember now. I remember that summer… I loved visiting with you and Dad tremendously, despite whatever Dad’s idiosyncrasies may have been.
Just like I used to worry about Dad, I used to worry about you. I thought about both of you all the time, and it was extremely upsetting to me to not get to see you and Dad on a regular basis. As you know, he was not good at staying in regular contact… He didn’t call, or write letters, or send birthday cards or anything like that. If I wanted to talk to him, I had to call him. And I did… but it was hard to understand why he couldn’t take the time to pick up the phone, or drop a card in the mail. It really hurt my feelings and I wondered why I wasn’t important enough to him for him to make the effort. Yet, I loved him anyway… and desperately craved his attention and affection. Deep down, I knew he loved me, and I believed he loved me. I told myself he didn’t call or send letters because it was too painful for him, not because he didn’t love me. But it still hurt my feelings.
I’m not sure if I saw you again after that very much at all until I moved to Chicago to live with you and Dad. I had no idea what I was walking into when I decided to do that… I had no idea what it would really be like to live there with Dad. Even still, I’m glad I did it… and even if I could go back and do it over, I wouldn’t change it. All things considered, I have no regrets about moving there… I got to spend time with you, I got to know Dad in a different way than I had ever known him before (which was both good and bad, if you know what I mean!). Also, if I hadn’t gone to Chicago, my kids wouldn’t exist… and I love them more than life!!
)
I do have a few regrets, however. I regret that I didn’t do more for you when I lived with you in Chicago. I knew I couldn’t leave you there alone, even if I hated Chicago. I could see that Dad was not doing a very good job of caring for you. It concerned me that he didn’t clean the house; that he didn’t seem to care about doing laundry, etc.
It concerned me that your mother wasn’t doing anything about it either… whether she really knew what was happening, I don’t know. I know I didn’t do as good a job as I could have… looking back I should have done more. I guess even though I was older than you, I was still just a kid, too. A selfish teenager, at that. I regret even more not staying in closer contact with you after you moved to Florida. I wish I had called more often, or sent you letters… I did to you what Dad did to me… I thought of you often, but did nothing to let you know that. I knew that you must have been having a difficult time… and I knew that your entire life had been full of difficulties, on a far greater level than mine had ever been. I knew that. I believed you would be taken better care of in Florida… that you would be better off there than with Dad, and hoped that you might finally get some stability and be able to be part of a semi-normal family. I knew it would be hard for you either way, whether you were with Dad or in Florida. I also knew that even if Florida was a better situation for you, it was going to be difficult.
Obviously it was more difficult for you than I could have predicted. I also had no idea how it must have been for you to live with Aunt or Grandma and Grandpa. When I listen to you describe what that was like, my heart breaks for you… I can’t imagine how alone you must have felt… or how helpless. I wish I could have been there and been able to help you. I wish I had been able to take you myself. I’m sure you still would have a difficult time with me, and who knows… maybe I would have totally sucked at helping you through all of the challenges and difficulties that lay ahead for you. Maybe you’d be in even worse shape now if you’d come to stay with me. I guess it’s pointless to think about it, since there’s no possibility of changing it now. In any event, I want you to know how sorry I am that I didn’t stay close with you… that I didn’t call or write regularly, that I didn’t do more for you to let you know you were loved and missed. I’m sorry I didn’t pay more attention—and that I was so wrapped up in my own world that I didn’t know how bad things were for you. I wish I had paid more attention…I wish I would have screamed at Aunt and at Grandma and whoever else needed to be screamed at to do a better job with you. As if they would have listened to me… Still, I wish I would have done it.
After you were sent back to Chicago, I had absolutely no clue (even less of a clue than ever) how difficult things were, or how much worse they were going to get for you. I can’t imagine how it must have been for you. Thank God (literally) that you were smart enough to seek out the help you needed, and that you have held on through your most difficult days. I can’t tell you how proud I am of you, and how much I admire your strength and courage. I am just so, so sorry that I lost contact with you for so long, and that I wasn’t there for you throughout your darkest days, when you most needed the love and support of your family. I am amazed that you have come through all of the unbelievable challenges and difficulties and CRAP that has been given to you the way you have… Honestly, it is utterly amazing to me. You are an amazing, beautiful, brave, incredible woman. You are a delight to me… and I feel lucky to know you.
You have special gifts to share with the world… One of them could be sharing your experiences and unique perspectives with other people… Your experiences could inspire other people to hang on and keep going, even when it feels impossible. Maybe someday you will write your story… and it will be a best seller, and help lots of people, and you will be a bajillionaire…
) Seriously, sharing your story with others, whether in a book, or just in your daily interactions with the people you meet and know in your everyday life (your sisters, your mom, the people in the support group, or whomever!) will touch and inspire other people.
I know you have touched and inspired me
I do think that regret is a useless emotion, unless it is used as motivation to do something different going forward. For me, that means making sure that forever forward, you know beyond the shadow of a doubt that I love you dearly, and that I am here for you always, always, always… and that you know that you are never alone… even though you may be halfway across the world from me. You can call me anytime, day or night… I will do whatever I can for you. Even if it’s 3 a.m., and you just need a person to talk to, you can call me! You don’t get to pick your family… I just got lucky that God gave me you for a sister. I am so thankful for that, my insert weird family nickname here.
Love forever and ever, Sister #1